13" MacBook Pro 2017 + [email protected] (Gigabyte Gaming Box) + macOS 10.14 + [taikuh]  

  RSS

Taikuh
(@taikuh)
Active Member
Joined: 10 months ago
Posts: 9
February 11, 2019 12:58 pm  

System specs

Model: 13" MacBook Pro 2017 w/ TouchBar
CPU: 3.5 GHz i7-7567U
iGPU: Intel Iris Plus 650
dGPU: none
OS: macOS 10.14.3


eGPU hardware

eGPU enclosure: Gigabyte Gaming Box
Video card: RX 580 inc. w/ enclosure


Hardware pictures

None yet.


Installation steps

No workable step-by-step yet. See comments.


Benchmarks

None yet.


Comments

This is very much a work in progress. I 'm completely stuck at the moment, but will update this post accordingly. I hope incomplete or failed builds can find a home here too.

First Attempt

I read that this box is pretty much plug and play with macOS, so I hooked the eGPU up to power with the provided cable, to my monitor (AOC 24P1) via Display Port, and then to my MBP with the provided TB3 cable to the top left port. At this time the MBP was in sleep mode and not connected to anything else. Immediately the MBP woke up, the eGPU LEDs lit up with fans spinning, MBP started charging, then the screen froze. Only moving the mouse was responsive; keyboard, touch bar, and mouse clicks were not registering. I disconnected the TB3 cable from my MBP and the system went black with some text saying there was a system error and the system will now restart.

Subsequent Attempts

When booting up the with eGPU plugged in, the boot up freezes — black screen with the white Apple logo and white progress bar halfway. If I unplug the eGPU, boot up will resume. If I plug the eGPU back in any time after this, the system will eventually freeze either at the login screen or at the desktop. I once saw a No GPU Detected notification in the corner.

I've tried with all 4 USB-C ports, without the external monitor, with another TB3 cable from the Mantiz Titan... No matter what, the system freezes. Meanwhile the eGPU is powered with the lights on and fans spinning.

I don't have boot camp installed, but I'll get to that in the coming days. Fingers crossed I find a way to make it work. At worst, I'll get a replacement box or just a refund and try another eGPU.

macOS Recovery Mode

With eGPU plugged in, boots into Recovery Mode just fine. No screen freeze or crashes. However, when connecting an external monitor to the eGPU, the external monitor's display is glitched. I've seen similar glitches with my 2011 MBP and Mac Mini due to GPU issues. I'm quite sure something similar is going on here that the eGPU is somehow faulty. This is how it looks like. The square block follows the mouse cursor. When I drag a window to the monitor, it appears behind the white bars.

Re-installing macOS

No improvement at all after re-installation. Everything is as it was in my previous attempts.

Boot Camp Attempts

I did the usual: install Windows 10 using Boot Camp, remove NVIDIA and AMD drivers with DDU, install rEFInd and edit refind.conf to spoof os x, plugged in the eGPU and install the AMD driver from Gigabyte support. Results are inconsistent except that ultimately the eGPU is unusable.

Booting Windows with the eGPU plugged in usually causes the boot up to hang. Boot up resumes normally after unplugging the eGPU. Plugging the eGPU back in any time after this yields similar results as macOS – a mostly frozen display except for the mouse, sometimes a black desktop and only the ability to right-click the task bar. After unplugging, Windows resumes as normal and the display refreshes itself according to whatever mouse and keyboard actions done prior.

Sometimes the eGPU LEDs aren't powered and the fan is unusually quiet when plugged in. These times, the display doesn't freeze. And device manager gives an Error 12. Disabling the right-side TB ports doesn't help. Sometimes plugging it into the lower left port (closest to TAB) disables the trackpad.


Because of the glitches in Recovery Mode, I'm fairly certain the eGPU itself is somehow faulty. I will return the eGPU to Amazon and get a refund. Unfortunately Amazon no longer has it in stock, so I can't get a replacement. As for other enclosures, I can't quite bring myself to spend $500+ on another enclosure and an RX 580 that will undoubtedly be bigger and more cumbersome than the RX 580 Gaming Box, which I got for $400.

I'm open to any and all suggestions, questions, and comments.

This topic was modified 6 days ago

Pending: Add my system information and expected eGPU configuration to my signature to give context to my posts


theitsage liked
ReplyQuote
Eightarmedpet
(@eightarmedpet)
Noble Member
Joined: 2 years ago
Posts: 1315

theitsage liked
ReplyQuote
Taikuh
(@taikuh)
Active Member
Joined: 10 months ago
Posts: 9
February 14, 2019 8:12 pm  

Sorry, couldn't log in for the past week. Update after trying macOS Recovery Mode, re-installing macOS, and using Boot Camp. Long story short, no dice.

macOS Recovery Mode

With eGPU plugged in, boots into Recovery Mode just fine. No screen freeze or crashes. However, when connecting an external monitor to the eGPU, the external monitor's display is glitched. I've seen similar glitches with my 2011 MBP and Mac Mini due to GPU issues. I'm quite sure something similar is going on here that the eGPU is somehow faulty. This is how it looks like. The square block follows the mouse cursor. When I drag a window to the monitor, it appears behind the white bars.

Re-installing macOS

No improvement at all after re-installation. Everything is as it was in my previous attempts.

Boot Camp Attempts

I did the usual: install Windows 10 using Boot Camp, remove NVIDIA and AMD drivers with DDU, install rEFInd and edit refind.conf to spoof os x, plugged in the eGPU and install the AMD driver from Gigabyte support. Results are inconsistent except that ultimately the eGPU is unusable.

Booting Windows with the eGPU plugged in usually causes the boot up to hang. Boot up resumes normally after unplugging the eGPU. Plugging the eGPU back in any time after this yields similar results as macOS – a mostly frozen display except for the mouse, sometimes a black desktop and only the ability to right-click the task bar. After unplugging, Windows resumes as normal and the display refreshes itself according to whatever mouse and keyboard actions done prior.

Sometimes the eGPU LEDs aren't powered and the fan is unusually quiet when plugged in. These times, the display doesn't freeze. And device manager gives an Error 12. Disabling the right-side TB ports doesn't help. Sometimes plugging it into the lower left port (closest to TAB) disables the trackpad.


Because of the glitches in Recovery Mode, I'm fairly certain the eGPU itself is somehow faulty. I will return the eGPU to Amazon and get a refund. Unfortunately Amazon no longer has it in stock, so I can't get a replacement. As for other enclosures, I can't quite bring myself to spend $500+ on another enclosure and an RX 580 that will undoubtedly be bigger and more cumbersome than the RX 580 Gaming Box, which I got for $400.

Pending: Add my system information and expected eGPU configuration to my signature to give context to my posts


ReplyQuote