Enclosure & Hardware Discussions
ALERT: half H2D performance issue on TI83 TB3 enclosures (Node, Venus, Devil Box...
 

ALERT: half H2D performance issue on TI83 TB3 enclosures (Node, Venus, Devil Box, XG Station 2)  

 of  8
  RSS

thendless
(@thendless)
Active Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 
Posted by: switch

Just a quick heads-up: Gigabyte's Aorus Gaming Box has the same problem. I've contacted Gigabyte but have received no reply.

Just confirmed that they will be addressing it in the future 🙂  https://www.reddit.com/r/gigabytegaming/comments/6ppttc/aorus_gaming_box_half_h2d_performance_issue_on/

Pending: Add my system information and expected eGPU configuration to my signature to give context to my posts


nando4 liked
ReplyQuote
Jaye
 Jaye
(@jaye)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

I'm curious. What if we all post to intel forums asking for limit removal of thunderbolt3? Unleash 10GB of speed for eGPU?

2017 13" HP Spectre 13" x360 + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10
2016 15" Asus UX501VW GTX960M + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10


ReplyQuote
jonwatso
(@jonwatso)
Trusted Member
Joined: 3 years ago
 
Posted by: Jaye

I'm curious. What if we all post to intel forums asking for limit removal of thunderbolt3? Unleash 10GB of speed for eGPU?

Would this be possible, is it simply just a firmware limitation? 

2017 15" MacBook Pro RP560 i7 3.1Ghz - 16GB RAM
Akitio Node + Sapphire RX480 8GB (Reference Card)
Dell 4K DELL P2715Q Display


ReplyQuote
wimpzilla
(@wimpzilla)
Honorable Member
Joined: 3 years ago
 
Posted by: Jaye

I'm curious. What if we all post to intel forums asking for limit removal of thunderbolt3? Unleash 10GB of speed for eGPU?

Hello, 

What is mostly needed is optimizations and fix on existing hardware, what you mostly read about the topic are issues that reflect the lack of TB software optimization regarding eGPU utilization.

What is generally brought as hardware bottleneck is generally a software bottleneck, the mislead came from the lack of knowledge of some users, especially regarding the hardware and how it really work, a big issue on this forum imo.

Instead of asking Intel to remove things, it would be preferable to open a discussion with Intel about the firmware development and validation, along manufacturers.

In a way that could be easier for manufacturer to implement full speed eGPU. For example with more dynamic and flexible threshold for the pci-e/display data routing through TB, especially if not using the display data. So ask an implementation of the data routing instead of a lock removal.

The TB eGPU work well, it just need some optimization on minimum FPS while in game, that i think is the result of suddenly reducing TB bandwidth and increased data latency when the game scene became more heavy than usual and due to an increased load on the TB controller.

 

2012 13-inch Dell Latitude E6320 + R9 [email protected] (EXP GDC 8.4) + Win10
E=Mc²


jonwatso liked
ReplyQuote
wkarma
(@wkarma)
New Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

Copying this here from the mantiz thread:

 

I recently received the Mantiz Venus and am using with a new 13.3 Razer Blade Stealth. My impression was that this issue had been fixed on the Venus, but I am still seeing it running CUDA-Z. Is there a firmware update I need to do?

 

CUDA-Z Report

=============

Version: 0.10.251 64 bit  http://cuda-z.sf.net/ 

OS Version: Windows x86 6.2.9200 

Driver Version: 384.94

Driver Dll Version: 9.0 (6.14.13.8494)

Runtime Dll Version: 6.50




Core Information

----------------

	Name: GeForce GTX 980

	Compute Capability: 5.2

	Clock Rate: 1342 MHz

	PCI Location: 0:7:0

	Multiprocessors: 16 (2048 Cores)

	Threads Per Multiproc.: 2048

	Warp Size: 32

	Regs Per Block: 65536

	Threads Per Block: 1024

	Threads Dimensions: 1024 x 1024 x 64

	Grid Dimensions: 2147483647 x 65535 x 65535

	Watchdog Enabled: Yes

	Integrated GPU: No

	Concurrent Kernels: Yes

	Compute Mode: Default

	Stream Priorities: Yes




Memory Information

------------------

	Total Global: 4096 MiB

	Bus Width: 256 bits

	Clock Rate: 3505 MHz

	Error Correction: No

	L2 Cache Size: 48 KiB

	Shared Per Block: 48 KiB

	Pitch: 2048 MiB

	Total Constant: 64 KiB

	Texture Alignment: 512 B

	Texture 1D Size: 65536

	Texture 2D Size: 65536 x 65536

	Texture 3D Size: 4096 x 4096 x 4096

	GPU Overlap: Yes

	Map Host Memory: Yes

	Unified Addressing: Yes

	Async Engine: Yes, Bidirectional




Performance Information

-----------------------

Memory Copy

	Host Pinned to Device: 1298.41 MiB/s

	Host Pageable to Device: 1160.76 MiB/s

	Device to Host Pinned: 2667.38 MiB/s

	Device to Host Pageable: 2166.02 MiB/s

	Device to Device: 72.8615 GiB/s

GPU Core Performance

	Single-precision Float: 5358.26 Gflop/s

	Double-precision Float: 175.209 Gflop/s

	64-bit Integer: 358.456 Giop/s

	32-bit Integer: 1657.26 Giop/s

	24-bit Integer: 1214.8 Giop/s




Generated: Thu Jul 27 23:08:09 2017

 

Pending: Add my system information and expected eGPU configuration to my signature to give context to my posts


ReplyQuote
Jaye
 Jaye
(@jaye)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 
Posted by: wimpzilla
Posted by: Jaye

I'm curious. What if we all post to intel forums asking for limit removal of thunderbolt3? Unleash 10GB of speed for eGPU?

Hello, 

What is mostly needed is optimizations and fix on existing hardware, what you mostly read about the topic are issues that reflect the lack of TB software optimization regarding eGPU utilization.

What is generally brought as hardware bottleneck is generally a software bottleneck, the mislead came from the lack of knowledge of some users, especially regarding the hardware and how it really work, a big issue on this forum imo.

Instead of asking Intel to remove things, it would be preferable to open a discussion with Intel about the firmware development and validation, along manufacturers.

In a way that could be easier for manufacturer to implement full speed eGPU. For example with more dynamic and flexible threshold for the pci-e/display data routing through TB, especially if not using the display data. So ask an implementation of the data routing instead of a lock removal.

The TB eGPU work well, it just need some optimization on minimum FPS while in game, that i think is the result of suddenly reducing TB bandwidth and increased data latency when the game scene became more heavy than usual and due to an increased load on the TB controller.

 

I don't think that Intel would allow manufacturers now to modify their firmware, at least not until Thunderbolt 3 will be more "free" in 2018.

As for now there is problem not only with drop on high fps (I don't really care about it, I have 60hz display), but also problem with low fps throughout all games.

Honestly, I'm kinda confused about H2D speed issues. From my experience, even games like WoW are struggling in heavy scenes - I don't see any reasons other than limited H2D speed. I remember how worse performance in WoW been before H2D fix..

Anyway, I just want this situation to move on - increase performance where it is possible either by new firmware \ speed limit increase (from 22 to 32gb) on by any other means. 

Why WoW, on my Akitio with 1080 ti, gives me 180 fps in some locations whereas in locations, with some (not too many) players in it, it drops to 48? Optimization? Desktop doesn't have this issue. Because of bandwidth? Because of bad decoding algorithm on TB3? CPU? (I have 6700hq, it should not bottleneck) Assassin's Creed Unity gives me stable 60 fps, but drops to 46 fps in "assassin's base" building. Assassin's Creed 4 Black Flag drops to 45 fps in jungle if environment quality is set to high or ultra (doesn't matter). If environment setting set to medium or low - less detailed trees and stable 60 fps throughout all game. I know Ubisoft optimization problems, but on 1080 ti? What about Blizzard's WoW game? What about GTA 5? Even GTA 5 has fps spikes.

Once again, I just want to rise this problem to everyone, who can do something for performance increase. Maybe eGPU companies like Akitio can ask for eGPU firmware (without 10gb reserved for display port)? Maybe Intel can do something?

P.S. Sorry for my English - not native language. 

2017 13" HP Spectre 13" x360 + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10
2016 15" Asus UX501VW GTX960M + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10


ReplyQuote
wimpzilla
(@wimpzilla)
Honorable Member
Joined: 3 years ago
 
Posted by: Jaye
Posted by: wimpzilla
Posted by: Jaye

I'm curious. What if we all post to intel forums asking for limit removal of thunderbolt3? Unleash 10GB of speed for eGPU?

Hello, 

What is mostly needed is optimizations and fix on existing hardware, what you mostly read about the topic are issues that reflect the lack of TB software optimization regarding eGPU utilization.

What is generally brought as hardware bottleneck is generally a software bottleneck, the mislead came from the lack of knowledge of some users, especially regarding the hardware and how it really work, a big issue on this forum imo.

Instead of asking Intel to remove things, it would be preferable to open a discussion with Intel about the firmware development and validation, along manufacturers.

In a way that could be easier for manufacturer to implement full speed eGPU. For example with more dynamic and flexible threshold for the pci-e/display data routing through TB, especially if not using the display data. So ask an implementation of the data routing instead of a lock removal.

The TB eGPU work well, it just need some optimization on minimum FPS while in game, that i think is the result of suddenly reducing TB bandwidth and increased data latency when the game scene became more heavy than usual and due to an increased load on the TB controller.

 

I don't think that Intel would allow manufacturers now to modify their firmware, at least not until Thunderbolt 3 will be more "free" in 2018.

As for now there is problem not only with drop on high fps (I don't really care about it, I have 60hz display), but also problem with low fps throughout all games.

Honestly, I'm kinda confused about H2D speed issues. From my experience, even games like WoW are struggling in heavy scenes - I don't see any reasons other than limited H2D speed. I remember how worse performance in WoW been before H2D fix..

Anyway, I just want this situation to move on - increase performance where it is possible either by new firmware \ speed limit increase (from 22 to 32gb) on by any other means. 

Why WoW, on my Akitio with 1080 ti, gives me 180 fps in some locations whereas in locations, with some (not too many) players in it, it drops to 48? Optimization? Desktop doesn't have this issue. Because of bandwidth? Because of bad decoding algorithm on TB3? CPU? (I have 6700hq, it should not bottleneck) Assassin's Creed Unity gives me stable 60 fps, but drops to 46 fps in "assassin's base" building. Assassin's Creed 4 Black Flag drops to 45 fps in jungle if environment quality is set to high or ultra (doesn't matter). If environment setting set to medium or low - less detailed trees and stable 60 fps throughout all game. I know Ubisoft optimization problems, but on 1080 ti? What about Blizzard's WoW game? What about GTA 5? Even GTA 5 has fps spikes.

Once again, I just want to rise this problem to everyone, who can do something for performance increase. Maybe eGPU companies like Akitio can ask for eGPU firmware (without 10gb reserved for display port)? Maybe Intel can do something?

P.S. Sorry for my English - not native language. 

Hello,

To picture you the hardware market, Intel is the manufacture that build the cpu along the platform/chipset and develop TB features.

There is not much more where to go, every piece of hardware in your laptop is based on Intel platform engineering.

So every manufacturer that come after Intel to use it's platform, can't always be free to implement whatever it wish without a cost.

Since the laptop market is quite huge and there is no laptop marketed for sole eGPU purpose, you need to carefully review each model and then choose the best one.

And find one that not bottleneck a 1080Ti at 1080pi is a hard task. Generally the ones with this kind of hardware already mount a 1070/1080 aboard.

 

 

2012 13-inch Dell Latitude E6320 + R9 [email protected] (EXP GDC 8.4) + Win10
E=Mc²


ReplyQuote
Jaye
 Jaye
(@jaye)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

In last few days I've contacted both Intel and Akitio for any possible thunderbolt 3 software optimizations.

Intel told that I should contact ASUS to ask them to replicate bottleneck issue - would not really help I think. Intel also told that they do not limit any changes to thunderbolt firmware - developer can do whatever he wants to his device firmware, Intel will only certify it.

Akitio customer support representative told me that he checked post about 22GB speed of thunderbolt 3 and that Akitio Node works as fast as it can and there is nothing to improve. 

 

Seems like there is nothing we can do - dead end. 

2017 13" HP Spectre 13" x360 + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10
2016 15" Asus UX501VW GTX960M + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10


nando4 and itsage liked
ReplyQuote
wimpzilla
(@wimpzilla)
Honorable Member
Joined: 3 years ago
 
Posted by: Jaye

In last few days I've contacted both Intel and Akitio for any possible thunderbolt 3 software optimizations.

Intel told that I should contact ASUS to ask them to replicate bottleneck issue - would not really help I think. Intel also told that they do not limit any changes to thunderbolt firmware - developer can do whatever he wants to his device firmware, Intel will only certify it.

Akitio customer support representative told me that he checked post about 22GB speed of thunderbolt 3 and that Akitio Node works as fast as it can and there is nothing to improve. 

 

Seems like there is nothing we can do - dead end. 

Well, you are maybe the only person that at least took the time to understand and move forward on this topic, congrats.

I do not see other users doing that, instead only complaining on things that are not clearly understood and simply criticized!

I did not found the same idea on this forum from when i registered, began to post and now that i'm not posting so much.

It is not a dead end you are mistaking, it completely the opposite. You just open a road for future improvement, dunno if you get that.

Again read my 1st answer to you and it is exactly what manufacturers told you. Test things carefully, explain them the issue, possibly with people that have the knowledge to put the issue in the right way.

Bring solid proof review of the issue and the relative gain for the consumer with no loss for the manufacturer. Discuss, rinse and repeat!

What is not done here in general, simply because there is no real interest to do that or maybe the lack of knowledge, really dunno. I stopped to ask myself the question.

So at then end of the journey, if you take time to discuss instead to criticize, you end up with a constructive thing.

Obviously, again, one can discuss if he know what he is speaking about and what is the final aim of the constructive discussion!

2012 13-inch Dell Latitude E6320 + R9 [email protected] (EXP GDC 8.4) + Win10
E=Mc²


ReplyQuote
Jaye
 Jaye
(@jaye)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

Thank you! 🙂

Well, I'm not english-proficient enough to continue work on this issue.

It is also curious that Nvidia released eGPU driver for Quadro - maybe it has some eGPU-oriented performance improvements? 

2017 13" HP Spectre 13" x360 + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10
2016 15" Asus UX501VW GTX960M + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10


ReplyQuote
wimpzilla
(@wimpzilla)
Honorable Member
Joined: 3 years ago
 
Posted by: Jaye

Thank you! 🙂

Well, I'm not english-proficient enough to continue work on this issue.

It is also curious that Nvidia released eGPU driver for Quadro - maybe it has some eGPU-oriented performance improvements? 

Nope, i don't think there is any major improvement eGPU gaming side.

It is to balance the driver performances of the Nvidia GTX cards, especially the the GTX Ti and Xp toward computing and professional use.

Since AMD Vega is out and it is quite a monster on computing side, Nvidia decided to unlock some features reserved to the Quadro cards to propose better computing performances.

AMD Vega is quite good at computing in professional applications rather than at gaming at the moment, beating depending the test, the GTX Ti or XP on professional use.

 

 

2012 13-inch Dell Latitude E6320 + R9 [email protected] (EXP GDC 8.4) + Win10
E=Mc²


ReplyQuote
switch
(@switch)
Trusted Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

Just got word from a reliable Gigabyte source that there's a firmware update upcoming for the Aorus which frees up the bandwidth. No ETA though. Apparently, they knew about the problem before release and have been testing internally new firmware.

2016 15" HP ZBook 15 G3 (Xeon E3-1545M, Iris Pro p580, no dGPU) + [email protected] (Aorus Gaming Box) + Win10pro
2018 15" HP ZBook 15 G5 (i7-8850H, HD630, Quadro P1000) + [email protected] (Aorus Gaming Box) + Win10pro


goalque, itsage and nando4 liked
ReplyQuote
Jaye
 Jaye
(@jaye)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

Ok, I want to share some observations regarding performance issues on Thunderbolt 3 connection.

I'm not going to show Assassin's Creed Black Flag issue (I mentioned it few times before and people blamed me for using not optimized games as example), but I'll show World of Warcraft game as example.

Not sure what exactly causes the issue (maybe it is affected not only by H2D speed), but this problem repeatable both on internal and external screen with ANY resolution in game. 

My setup: UX501VW laptop (officially works with egpu + bios & tb3 fw update) and ROG Strix 1080Ti. 

Game shows EXACTLY same FPS value on heavy scenes with ANY resolution.

800x600 (used almost lowest possible):

2560x1440 (2K):

 

Once again, FPS is 46-48 on both internal and external screen with any resolution. Desktop 1080Ti doesn't have this issue.

 P.S. Normal performance in this game on my setup is between 80-160FPS.

2017 13" HP Spectre 13" x360 + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10
2016 15" Asus UX501VW GTX960M + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10


ReplyQuote
switch
(@switch)
Trusted Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

V-Sync or similar?

Install GPU-Z, let it run in the background with logging turned on then look at the graphs. I don't think you'll see too much of an impact on PCIe bandwidth.

I think the problem is related to the laptop not the eGPU setup.

 

2016 15" HP ZBook 15 G3 (Xeon E3-1545M, Iris Pro p580, no dGPU) + [email protected] (Aorus Gaming Box) + Win10pro
2018 15" HP ZBook 15 G5 (i7-8850H, HD630, Quadro P1000) + [email protected] (Aorus Gaming Box) + Win10pro


ReplyQuote
Azrael
(@azrael)
Active Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 
[Gigabyte Aorus GTX 1070 GAMING BOX]

Hi everyone,

I contacted the gigabyte support for the H2D issue a while ago, and I actually got a reply (very nice). Now I am looking for advice on an answer from those here that have some more knowledge about the issue. Here is the conversation:

Dear Sir or Madam,

I would like to purchase the GTX 1070 Gaming Box and become one of your customers. However, I have recently become aware of an issue with the performance of this external GPU.

The following thread details the "half Host-to-Device performance issue" that seems to be caused by the Thunderbolt 3 firmware:
https://egpu.io/forums/thunderbolt-enclosures/alert-akitio-node-half-h2d-bandwidth-issue/

My questions are:
Do you acknowledge this as being a problem?
Are you working on a solution?

Sincerely

Answer from gigabyte:

From our current test result using 3D Mark11 on related products from our own brand or compatitors', it does not make much difference between new and old firmware released by Intel. If you faced any performance on our product or you saw other people with the problem with our product, please provide us the following information so our engineer can try to verify:

1. Product serial number

2. What is system hardware configuration?

3. How did you / they generate the performance impact? Please provide us the screen shot of the performance result which shows in your / their platform. 

the more detail you can provide, the better we can replicate the issue.

Things I considered for the answer:

  • Thanking them for getting in thouch with me
  • Telling them that I actually bought a unit, so I have a serial number and can give them my hardware config
  • I can provide a CUDA-Z Screenshot with Host to Device = 1190 MiB/s (and Device to Host 2660 MiB/s)
  • Now for this I need your advice: My impression from this forum was that the H2D is more of a theoretical issue, and hardly affects FPS in gaming. It might be a limiting factor when using the TB3 for networking, fast external harddrives and GPU usage at the same time.
  • Is this wrong / right / should I consider something else in my response?

Cheers!

Pending: Add my system information and expected eGPU configuration to my signature to give context to my posts


itsage liked
ReplyQuote
itsage
(@itsage)
Famed Member Admin
Joined: 3 years ago
 

My guess is there’s a pushback from Intel on this H2D issue. Theoretical or not, asking the customers who have limited resources and knowledge about TB3 eGPU to provide evidence of performance loss is not a fair tactic. Intel should be the one to provide concrete data and documentation showing there’s no difference between an eGPU setup at half H2D vs. another at full H2D.

Best ultrabooks for eGPU use

eGPU enclosure buying guide


nando4 liked
ReplyQuote
nando4
(@nando4)
Noble Member Admin
Joined: 3 years ago
 

@Azrael, you have purchased a Thunderbolt3 product which in Intel’s fine print delivers 22Gbps of PCIe bandwidth. You are getting half that in the important host-to-device direction, giving performance equivalent to Thunderbolt2. You can see measured performance at:

https://egpu.io/external-gpu-implementations-table/#perf

You are in a position to request a fix to deliver performance according to spec or negotiate a partial or obtain a full refund for performance underdelivery. Half bandwidth isn’t a case of “it’s near enough”.

eGPU Setup 1.35    •    eGPU Port Bandwidth Reference Table


ReplyQuote
switch
(@switch)
Trusted Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

That's the default reply. I had to band them over the head with the TB3 controller and USB-C controller specifications before the ACKed the issue and I got a techie's reply.

2016 15" HP ZBook 15 G3 (Xeon E3-1545M, Iris Pro p580, no dGPU) + [email protected] (Aorus Gaming Box) + Win10pro
2018 15" HP ZBook 15 G5 (i7-8850H, HD630, Quadro P1000) + [email protected] (Aorus Gaming Box) + Win10pro


ReplyQuote
Jaye
 Jaye
(@jaye)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 
Posted by: switch

V-Sync or similar?

Install GPU-Z, let it run in the background with logging turned on then look at the graphs. I don't think you'll see too much of an impact on PCIe bandwidth.

I think the problem is related to the laptop not the eGPU setup.

 

No V-Sync or anything like this.

What could be wrong with laptop? 6700HQ bottleneck? On this graph exactly same scene is in the middle of log.

        Date        , GPU Core Clock [MHz] , GPU Memory Clock [MHz] , GPU Temperature [°C] , Fan Speed (%) [%] , Fan Speed (RPM) [RPM] , Memory Used [MB] , GPU Load [%] , Memory Controller Load [%] , Video Engine Load [%] , Bus Interface Load [%] , Power Consumption [% TDP] , PerfCap Reason [] , VDDC [V] ,
2017-08-18 12:46:08 ,              139.0   ,                405.0   ,               34.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1704   ,          0   ,                        3   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     5.8   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:09 ,              139.0   ,                405.0   ,               34.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1700   ,          0   ,                        3   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     6.1   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:10 ,              139.0   ,                405.0   ,               34.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1696   ,         19   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                    5   ,                     7.3   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:11 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               36.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1705   ,         35   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    40.1   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:12 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               36.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1705   ,         35   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    40.6   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:13 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               36.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1706   ,         35   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    36.7   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:14 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               36.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1704   ,         33   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    40.8   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:15 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               37.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1706   ,         32   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    37.3   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:16 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               37.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1705   ,         33   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    35.3   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:17 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               37.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1722   ,         31   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    39.8   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:18 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               37.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1734   ,         30   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    31.1   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:19 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               37.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1740   ,         31   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    40.6   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:20 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               37.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1745   ,         29   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    40.1   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:21 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               37.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1766   ,         26   ,                        6   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    31.3   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:22 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               37.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1802   ,         28   ,                        6   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    34.4   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:23 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               37.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1815   ,         25   ,                        6   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    36.2   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:24 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               37.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1830   ,         27   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    35.1   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:25 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               38.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1832   ,         26   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    37.0   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:26 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               37.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1836   ,         28   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    36.0   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:27 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               38.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1843   ,         27   ,                        5   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    32.8   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:28 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               38.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1847   ,         31   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   11   ,                    32.6   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:29 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               38.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1842   ,         34   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    35.0   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:30 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               38.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1842   ,         35   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    35.4   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:31 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               38.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1845   ,         33   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    32.6   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:32 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               38.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1848   ,         35   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    32.4   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:33 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               38.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1845   ,         36   ,                        6   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    33.8   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:34 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               38.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1850   ,         31   ,                        6   ,                   0   ,                   11   ,                    35.3   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:35 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               38.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1855   ,         34   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    33.4   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:36 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1855   ,         38   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    32.6   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:37 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1855   ,         38   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    32.6   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:38 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1855   ,         36   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    39.2   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:39 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1856   ,         40   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    32.4   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:40 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1856   ,         35   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    33.3   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:41 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1856   ,         37   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    37.3   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:42 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1857   ,         37   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    32.4   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:43 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1860   ,         34   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    39.0   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:44 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1864   ,         36   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    39.4   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:45 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1865   ,         37   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    38.1   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:46 ,             1645.0   ,               5508.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1865   ,         37   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    39.3   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:47 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1878   ,         36   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    37.7   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:48 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1879   ,         39   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   15   ,                    34.8   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:49 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1881   ,         34   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    34.1   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:50 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1882   ,         33   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    34.3   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:51 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1882   ,         37   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   15   ,                    34.0   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:52 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1882   ,         35   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    35.8   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:53 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1883   ,         35   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    34.4   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:54 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1882   ,         36   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    39.1   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:55 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               41.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1881   ,         33   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    33.2   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:56 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               41.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1881   ,         38   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    37.9   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:57 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               41.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1880   ,         37   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    35.7   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:58 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               41.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1887   ,         38   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    37.6   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:46:59 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               41.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1888   ,         25   ,                        6   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    36.2   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:00 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               41.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1893   ,         24   ,                        5   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    35.9   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:01 ,             1695.5   ,               5508.0   ,               41.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1892   ,         24   ,                        6   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    38.7   ,              16   , 0.9250   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:02 ,             1328.5   ,               5005.8   ,               41.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1882   ,         29   ,                        7   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    29.1   ,              16   , 0.7500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:03 ,             1328.5   ,               5005.8   ,               41.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1886   ,         33   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    31.6   ,              16   , 0.7500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:04 ,             1177.0   ,               5005.8   ,               41.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1886   ,         33   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    30.6   ,              16   , 0.7250   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:05 ,             1177.0   ,               5005.8   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1888   ,          5   ,                        0   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    22.7   ,              16   , 0.7250   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:06 ,             1177.0   ,               5005.8   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1888   ,          2   ,                        0   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    23.0   ,              16   , 0.7250   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:07 ,              721.0   ,                810.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1888   ,          0   ,                        1   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     7.6   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:08 ,              721.0   ,                810.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1888   ,          0   ,                        1   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     7.9   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:09 ,              721.0   ,                810.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1888   ,          0   ,                        1   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     7.6   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:10 ,              164.5   ,                405.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1888   ,          0   ,                        3   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     6.2   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:11 ,              164.5   ,                405.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1889   ,          0   ,                        3   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     6.2   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:12 ,              164.5   ,                405.0   ,               40.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1891   ,          2   ,                        3   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     6.5   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:13 ,              139.0   ,                405.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1891   ,          0   ,                        3   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     6.1   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:14 ,              139.0   ,                405.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1891   ,          0   ,                        3   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     6.3   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:15 ,              139.0   ,                405.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1891   ,          0   ,                        3   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     5.9   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:16 ,              139.0   ,                405.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1891   ,          0   ,                        3   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     6.1   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:17 ,              139.0   ,                405.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1891   ,          0   ,                        3   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     6.1   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,
2017-08-18 12:47:18 ,              139.0   ,                405.0   ,               39.0   ,               0   ,                   0   ,           1891   ,          0   ,                        3   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                     6.5   ,              16   , 0.6500   ,

2017 13" HP Spectre 13" x360 + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10
2016 15" Asus UX501VW GTX960M + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10


ReplyQuote
Jaye
 Jaye
(@jaye)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

I wonder what % means on bus load? 100% - Pci-e X16?  Or 100% - pci-e x4? 

Assassin's Creed with issue that I described (Highest bus values - environmental details set on maximum):

        Date        , GPU Core Clock [MHz] , GPU Memory Clock [MHz] , GPU Temperature [°C] , Fan Speed (%) [%] , Fan Speed (RPM) [RPM] , Memory Used [MB] , GPU Load [%] , Memory Controller Load [%] , Video Engine Load [%] , Bus Interface Load [%] , Power Consumption [% TDP] , PerfCap Reason [] , VDDC [V] ,
2017-08-18 13:09:51 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               52.0   ,              22   ,                1175   ,           2529   ,          1   ,                        0   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    27.7   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:09:52 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               52.0   ,              22   ,                1089   ,           2521   ,          2   ,                        0   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    27.4   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:09:53 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               52.0   ,              21   ,                   0   ,           2498   ,         13   ,                        0   ,                   0   ,                    5   ,                    27.4   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:09:54 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               53.0   ,              21   ,                 963   ,           2546   ,         63   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    49.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:09:55 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               54.0   ,              21   ,                1170   ,           2546   ,         65   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    53.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:09:56 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               53.0   ,              21   ,                1089   ,           2530   ,          0   ,                        0   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    34.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:09:57 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               53.0   ,              21   ,                   0   ,           2521   ,          0   ,                        0   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    34.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:09:59 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               53.0   ,              21   ,                1151   ,           2513   ,          0   ,                        0   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    35.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:09:59 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               53.0   ,              20   ,                1123   ,           2561   ,         87   ,                       15   ,                   0   ,                   21   ,                    57.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:00 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               54.0   ,              20   ,                1057   ,           2561   ,         86   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                   18   ,                    44.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:01 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               54.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2561   ,         84   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   21   ,                    53.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:02 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               54.0   ,              20   ,                1202   ,           2561   ,         77   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    56.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:03 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               54.0   ,              20   ,                1127   ,           2561   ,         81   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    56.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:04 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               54.0   ,              20   ,                1077   ,           2561   ,         85   ,                       15   ,                   0   ,                   23   ,                    57.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:05 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               54.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2561   ,         82   ,                       15   ,                   0   ,                   21   ,                    55.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:06 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1182   ,           2561   ,         79   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    57.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:07 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1092   ,           2561   ,         75   ,                       16   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    63.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:08 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2561   ,         78   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    63.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:09 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                 961   ,           2561   ,         76   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    55.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:10 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1137   ,           2561   ,         80   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    60.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:11 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1072   ,           2561   ,         80   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   22   ,                    56.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:12 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2561   ,         85   ,                       16   ,                   0   ,                   22   ,                    53.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:13 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1191   ,           2537   ,         75   ,                       16   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    37.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:14 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1103   ,           2537   ,         82   ,                       17   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    54.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:15 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2537   ,         73   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    57.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:16 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                 940   ,           2537   ,         78   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    64.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:17 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1146   ,           2537   ,         71   ,                       16   ,                   0   ,                   16   ,                    52.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:18 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1064   ,           2537   ,         73   ,                       16   ,                   0   ,                   18   ,                    55.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:19 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2537   ,         69   ,                       15   ,                   0   ,                   16   ,                    58.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:20 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1185   ,           2537   ,         71   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                   23   ,                    54.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:21 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1104   ,           2537   ,         75   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                   17   ,                    64.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:22 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2537   ,         73   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                   16   ,                    62.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:23 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2537   ,         81   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    48.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:24 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1159   ,           2537   ,         74   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   18   ,                    54.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:25 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1084   ,           2537   ,         76   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                   18   ,                    51.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:26 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2559   ,         37   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    52.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:27 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1198   ,           2559   ,         30   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    49.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:28 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1115   ,           2561   ,         30   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    35.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:29 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2561   ,         30   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    58.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:30 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2561   ,         31   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    59.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:31 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1159   ,           2561   ,         31   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    50.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:32 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1078   ,           2561   ,         31   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    49.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:33 ,             1607.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2561   ,         34   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    39.6   ,              16   , 0.8810   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:34 ,             1607.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1118   ,           2561   ,         34   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    40.2   ,              16   , 0.8810   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:35 ,             1607.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1130   ,           2561   ,         34   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    42.2   ,              16   , 0.8810   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:36 ,             1607.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2561   ,         34   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    48.8   ,              16   , 0.8810   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:37 ,             1607.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2654   ,         27   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    42.4   ,              16   , 0.8810   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:38 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              20   ,                1173   ,           2655   ,         83   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   22   ,                    45.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:39 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1084   ,           2655   ,         76   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   21   ,                    55.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:40 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         77   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    46.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:41 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1051   ,           2655   ,         70   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   18   ,                    55.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:42 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1133   ,           2655   ,         79   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    49.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:43 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1076   ,           2655   ,         78   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   21   ,                    50.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:44 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         75   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   19   ,                    46.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:45 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1178   ,           2655   ,         74   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   18   ,                    47.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:46 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1094   ,           2655   ,         81   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   21   ,                    52.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:47 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         73   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   18   ,                    52.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:48 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                 711   ,           2655   ,         80   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    47.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:49 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1154   ,           2655   ,         79   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    43.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:50 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1073   ,           2655   ,         78   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   21   ,                    50.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:51 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         77   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   19   ,                    52.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:52 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1200   ,           2655   ,         77   ,                       12   ,                   0   ,                   22   ,                    49.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:53 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1123   ,           2655   ,         73   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                   17   ,                    46.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:54 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1078   ,           2660   ,         73   ,                       15   ,                   0   ,                   19   ,                    62.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:55 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                   0   ,           2660   ,         81   ,                       15   ,                   0   ,                   15   ,                    57.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:56 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1170   ,           2660   ,         84   ,                       15   ,                   0   ,                   15   ,                    51.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:57 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              20   ,                1094   ,           2660   ,         81   ,                       12   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    48.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:58 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              21   ,                   0   ,           2660   ,         78   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                   17   ,                    53.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:10:59 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              21   ,                 905   ,           2660   ,         73   ,                       15   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    53.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:00 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              21   ,                1159   ,           2660   ,         79   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    62.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:01 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              21   ,                1082   ,           2660   ,         81   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    57.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:02 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              21   ,                   0   ,           2660   ,         79   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    48.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:03 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              21   ,                 912   ,           2657   ,         36   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    45.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:04 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              21   ,                1163   ,           2658   ,         23   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    43.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:05 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              21   ,                1075   ,           2657   ,         23   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    55.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:06 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              21   ,                   0   ,           2657   ,         24   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    47.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:07 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              21   ,                1110   ,           2659   ,         26   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    59.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:08 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              21   ,                1151   ,           2659   ,         24   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    57.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:09 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              21   ,                1064   ,           2659   ,         24   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    54.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:10 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              21   ,                   0   ,           2659   ,         24   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    49.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:11 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              21   ,                1154   ,           2659   ,         24   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    55.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:12 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              21   ,                1153   ,           2659   ,         24   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    49.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:13 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              22   ,                1077   ,           2659   ,         24   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    51.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:14 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              22   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         81   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    55.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:15 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              22   ,                 835   ,           2655   ,         78   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    57.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:16 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              22   ,                1166   ,           2655   ,         75   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    53.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:17 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              22   ,                1098   ,           2655   ,         84   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    52.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:18 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              22   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         78   ,                       12   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    56.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:19 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              22   ,                 902   ,           2655   ,         82   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    52.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:20 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              22   ,                1155   ,           2655   ,         81   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    45.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:21 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              22   ,                1078   ,           2655   ,         79   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    53.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:22 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              22   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         78   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    50.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:23 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              22   ,                1123   ,           2655   ,         76   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    51.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:24 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              22   ,                1145   ,           2655   ,         76   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   22   ,                    48.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:25 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1071   ,           2655   ,         70   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    49.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:26 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         73   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    47.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:27 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1205   ,           2655   ,         75   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    56.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:28 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1137   ,           2655   ,         72   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   18   ,                    53.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:29 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1068   ,           2655   ,         71   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   18   ,                    44.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:30 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         72   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   18   ,                    48.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:31 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1219   ,           2655   ,         74   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   18   ,                    50.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:32 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1145   ,           2655   ,         75   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    53.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:33 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1073   ,           2655   ,         77   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   20   ,                    51.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:34 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         72   ,                       11   ,                   0   ,                   19   ,                    48.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:35 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1011   ,           2655   ,         76   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   21   ,                    48.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:36 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1161   ,           2655   ,         77   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   21   ,                    45.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:37 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1092   ,           2655   ,         65   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    56.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:38 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1031   ,           2652   ,         31   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    54.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:39 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                   0   ,           2653   ,         25   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    42.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:40 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1197   ,           2652   ,         22   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    46.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:41 ,             1569.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              23   ,                1123   ,           2654   ,         28   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    36.1   ,              16   , 0.8620   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:42 ,             1569.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              23   ,                1060   ,           2654   ,         25   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    41.3   ,              16   , 0.8620   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:43 ,             1569.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              23   ,                   0   ,           2654   ,         25   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    38.9   ,              16   , 0.8620   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:44 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               56.0   ,              23   ,                1209   ,           2654   ,         27   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    41.3   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:45 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              23   ,                1159   ,           2654   ,         27   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    40.2   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:46 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              23   ,                1084   ,           2654   ,         26   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    35.4   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:47 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              23   ,                1030   ,           2654   ,         27   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    40.1   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:48 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               55.0   ,              23   ,                   0   ,           2652   ,         26   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    40.4   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:49 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1184   ,           2655   ,         82   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    55.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:50 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1107   ,           2655   ,         82   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    57.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:51 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1023   ,           2655   ,         80   ,                       17   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    52.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:52 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         79   ,                       17   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    69.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:53 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               57.0   ,              23   ,                1194   ,           2655   ,         84   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    72.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:54 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               58.0   ,              23   ,                1137   ,           2654   ,         77   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    64.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:55 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               58.0   ,              23   ,                1072   ,           2655   ,         61   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    63.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:56 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               58.0   ,              24   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         66   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    61.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:57 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               58.0   ,              24   ,                 956   ,           2655   ,         63   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    64.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:58 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               58.0   ,              24   ,                1174   ,           2655   ,         59   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    56.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:11:59 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               58.0   ,              24   ,                1102   ,           2655   ,         52   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    58.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:00 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               58.0   ,              24   ,                1048   ,           2655   ,         56   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    5   ,                    60.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:01 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               58.0   ,              24   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         52   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    5   ,                    52.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:02 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               58.0   ,              24   ,                1207   ,           2655   ,         51   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    60.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:03 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               58.0   ,              24   ,                1150   ,           2655   ,         50   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    58.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:04 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               58.0   ,              24   ,                1085   ,           2655   ,         62   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    54.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:05 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               58.0   ,              24   ,                1021   ,           2655   ,         62   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    67.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:06 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              24   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         57   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    59.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:07 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              24   ,                1197   ,           2655   ,         56   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    66.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:08 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              24   ,                1145   ,           2655   ,         60   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    62.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:09 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              25   ,                1083   ,           2655   ,         85   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   11   ,                    67.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:10 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              25   ,                1040   ,           2655   ,         80   ,                       17   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    55.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:11 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              25   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         92   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    57.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:12 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              25   ,                1131   ,           2655   ,         91   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    57.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:13 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              25   ,                1179   ,           2655   ,         91   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    50.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:14 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              25   ,                1122   ,           2655   ,         89   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    57.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:15 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              25   ,                1070   ,           2654   ,         86   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    61.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:16 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              25   ,                1029   ,           2655   ,         80   ,                       23   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    74.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:17 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              25   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         70   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    62.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:18 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              26   ,                1200   ,           2655   ,         74   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    65.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:19 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              26   ,                1136   ,           2655   ,         72   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    69.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:20 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              26   ,                1078   ,           2655   ,         83   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    72.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:21 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              26   ,                1042   ,           2655   ,         70   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    68.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:22 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              26   ,                1003   ,           2655   ,         60   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    62.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:23 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              26   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         84   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    62.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:24 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              26   ,                1197   ,           2655   ,         92   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   11   ,                    61.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:25 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              26   ,                1140   ,           2655   ,         88   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    63.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:26 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              26   ,                1088   ,           2655   ,         90   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    60.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:27 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1051   ,           2655   ,         91   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    58.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:28 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1028   ,           2655   ,         89   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    55.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:29 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1015   ,           2655   ,         90   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    57.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:30 ,             1860.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                   0   ,           2655   ,         86   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    61.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:31 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1165   ,           2655   ,         88   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    67.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:32 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1186   ,           2655   ,         78   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    65.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:33 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1129   ,           2655   ,         86   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    53.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:34 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1084   ,           2655   ,         91   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    60.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:35 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1052   ,           2655   ,         90   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    58.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:36 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1033   ,           2655   ,         87   ,                       17   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    59.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:37 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1021   ,           2655   ,         86   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    48.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:38 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1015   ,           2655   ,         89   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    56.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:39 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1011   ,           2655   ,         87   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    64.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:40 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              27   ,                1008   ,           2655   ,         91   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    59.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:41 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              28   ,                1007   ,           2655   ,         89   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    60.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:42 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              28   ,                1007   ,           2655   ,         86   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    54.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:43 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              28   ,                1006   ,           2655   ,         85   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    65.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:44 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              28   ,                1007   ,           2655   ,         88   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    58.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:45 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              28   ,                1006   ,           2655   ,         87   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    67.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:46 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              28   ,                1007   ,           2655   ,         81   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    49.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:47 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              28   ,                1009   ,           2655   ,         84   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    60.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:48 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              28   ,                1010   ,           2655   ,         84   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    51.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:49 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              28   ,                1011   ,           2655   ,         78   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   11   ,                    65.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:50 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              28   ,                1014   ,           2655   ,         82   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   11   ,                    55.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:51 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              28   ,                1015   ,           2655   ,         64   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    67.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:52 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              28   ,                1018   ,           2655   ,         79   ,                       17   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    60.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:53 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              28   ,                1020   ,           2655   ,         83   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    59.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:54 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              29   ,                1024   ,           2655   ,         87   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    69.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:55 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              29   ,                1028   ,           2655   ,         89   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    59.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:56 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              29   ,                1031   ,           2655   ,         85   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    67.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:57 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              29   ,                1035   ,           2655   ,         87   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    70.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:58 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              29   ,                1039   ,           2655   ,         88   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    62.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:12:59 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              29   ,                1041   ,           2655   ,         80   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    68.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:00 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              29   ,                1046   ,           2649   ,         85   ,                       23   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    64.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:01 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              29   ,                1049   ,           2649   ,         74   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    68.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:02 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              29   ,                1055   ,           2650   ,         56   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    5   ,                    62.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:03 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1059   ,           2650   ,         54   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    69.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:04 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1065   ,           2650   ,         50   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    68.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:05 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1069   ,           2650   ,         66   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    58.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:06 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1074   ,           2649   ,         70   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    71.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:07 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1078   ,           2650   ,         71   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    68.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:08 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1080   ,           2650   ,         61   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    63.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:09 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1084   ,           2650   ,         55   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    5   ,                    59.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:10 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1088   ,           2650   ,         55   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    63.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:11 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1092   ,           2649   ,         80   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    65.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:12 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1093   ,           2649   ,         86   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    64.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:13 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1095   ,           2650   ,         79   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    65.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:14 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1096   ,           2649   ,         81   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    70.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:15 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              30   ,                1100   ,           2649   ,         87   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   11   ,                    72.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:16 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1104   ,           2610   ,         77   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    68.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:17 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1106   ,           2610   ,         72   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    67.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:18 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1111   ,           2610   ,         76   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    63.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:19 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1113   ,           2610   ,         77   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    65.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:20 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1116   ,           2611   ,         57   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    58.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:21 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1121   ,           2611   ,         53   ,                       17   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    56.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:22 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1122   ,           2611   ,         54   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    66.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:23 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1123   ,           2611   ,         52   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    58.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:24 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1126   ,           2611   ,         49   ,                       17   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    58.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:25 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1127   ,           2611   ,         51   ,                       16   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    62.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:26 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1127   ,           2611   ,         44   ,                       16   ,                   0   ,                    3   ,                    59.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:27 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1127   ,           2611   ,         56   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    5   ,                    61.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:28 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1131   ,           2610   ,         78   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    63.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:29 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1131   ,           2610   ,         81   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                   10   ,                    63.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:30 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1132   ,           2611   ,         42   ,                       17   ,                   0   ,                    3   ,                    57.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:31 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1132   ,           2611   ,         58   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    68.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:32 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1132   ,           2610   ,         93   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    66.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:33 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1132   ,           2610   ,         85   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   11   ,                    72.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:34 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1136   ,           2610   ,         43   ,                       17   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    57.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:35 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1137   ,           2610   ,         52   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    55.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:36 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1137   ,           2610   ,         57   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    61.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:37 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1137   ,           2610   ,         63   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    66.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:38 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1140   ,           2610   ,         97   ,                       23   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    67.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:39 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              31   ,                1141   ,           2665   ,         49   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    56.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:40 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              31   ,                1143   ,           2665   ,         93   ,                       23   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    68.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:41 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              31   ,                1141   ,           2665   ,         98   ,                       23   ,                   0   ,                   15   ,                    73.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:42 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              31   ,                1144   ,           2665   ,         90   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    66.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:43 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1145   ,           2665   ,         93   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    65.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:44 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1147   ,           2665   ,         96   ,                       23   ,                   0   ,                   15   ,                    72.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:45 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1149   ,           2665   ,         96   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    66.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:46 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1151   ,           2665   ,         90   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    64.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:47 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1153   ,           2665   ,         75   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    64.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:48 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1156   ,           2666   ,         58   ,                       15   ,                   0   ,                    5   ,                    58.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:49 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1157   ,           2665   ,         92   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    72.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:50 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1160   ,           2665   ,         92   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    64.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:51 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1163   ,           2665   ,         88   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    70.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:52 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1163   ,           2665   ,         91   ,                       24   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    66.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:53 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1167   ,           2665   ,         84   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    66.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:54 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1167   ,           2665   ,         92   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                   15   ,                    68.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:55 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1168   ,           2665   ,         92   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    73.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:56 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1171   ,           2665   ,         94   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   16   ,                    65.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:57 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1171   ,           2665   ,         93   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   15   ,                    68.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:58 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1175   ,           2665   ,         93   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                   15   ,                    67.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:13:59 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1175   ,           2665   ,         87   ,                       22   ,                   0   ,                   12   ,                    67.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:00 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1176   ,           2665   ,         91   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    70.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:01 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1179   ,           2665   ,         94   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   14   ,                    56.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:02 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1180   ,           2665   ,         85   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    64.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:03 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              32   ,                1182   ,           2665   ,         89   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    69.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:04 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              33   ,                1183   ,           2665   ,         89   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    63.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:05 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              33   ,                1183   ,           2665   ,         89   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                   13   ,                    71.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:06 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               63.0   ,              33   ,                1186   ,           2663   ,         23   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    57.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:07 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1189   ,           2663   ,         21   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    51.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:08 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1189   ,           2663   ,         22   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    55.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:09 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1190   ,           2663   ,         25   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    37.1   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:10 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1190   ,           2665   ,         28   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    36.7   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:11 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1193   ,           2665   ,         27   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    40.2   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:12 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              33   ,                1193   ,           2665   ,         25   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    38.5   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:13 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              33   ,                1192   ,           2665   ,         25   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    36.0   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:14 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              33   ,                1189   ,           2665   ,         26   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    36.3   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:15 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              33   ,                1190   ,           2663   ,         29   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    37.6   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:16 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1192   ,           2665   ,         69   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                    8   ,                    69.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:17 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1190   ,           2665   ,         60   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    64.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:18 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1190   ,           2665   ,         59   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    63.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:19 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1190   ,           2666   ,         52   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    5   ,                    60.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:20 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1190   ,           2665   ,         47   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    4   ,                    70.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:21 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1192   ,           2666   ,         36   ,                       12   ,                   0   ,                    3   ,                    58.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:22 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1192   ,           2666   ,         57   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    70.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:23 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1192   ,           2665   ,         49   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    60.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:24 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1190   ,           2665   ,         52   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    5   ,                    62.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:25 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1192   ,           2665   ,         56   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    71.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:26 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1193   ,           2665   ,         53   ,                       17   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    66.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:27 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1193   ,           2665   ,         56   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    57.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:28 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1192   ,           2665   ,         55   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    61.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:29 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1193   ,           2665   ,         57   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    7   ,                    64.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:30 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1193   ,           2665   ,         54   ,                       18   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    56.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:31 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1195   ,           2665   ,         51   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    58.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:32 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1193   ,           2665   ,         56   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    69.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:33 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1193   ,           2665   ,         57   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    60.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:34 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1192   ,           2665   ,         58   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    61.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:35 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1193   ,           2665   ,         55   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    63.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:36 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1193   ,           2665   ,         60   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    61.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:37 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1197   ,           2663   ,         22   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    55.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:38 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1199   ,           2663   ,         25   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    3   ,                    47.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:39 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1199   ,           2663   ,         21   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    46.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:40 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1196   ,           2665   ,         24   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    54.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:41 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1196   ,           2665   ,         24   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    46.6   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:42 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1199   ,           2665   ,         23   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    44.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:43 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1196   ,           2665   ,         23   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    50.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:44 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1199   ,           2665   ,         23   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    47.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:45 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1196   ,           2663   ,          9   ,                        4   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    48.8   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:46 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1196   ,           2641   ,         62   ,                       16   ,                   0   ,                    9   ,                    56.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:47 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1197   ,           2641   ,         74   ,                       16   ,                   0   ,                   17   ,                    58.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:48 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               62.0   ,              33   ,                1197   ,           2641   ,         77   ,                       15   ,                   0   ,                   21   ,                    51.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:49 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1199   ,           2641   ,         73   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                   22   ,                    47.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:50 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1197   ,           2641   ,         73   ,                       14   ,                   0   ,                   21   ,                    52.5   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:51 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1197   ,           2646   ,         75   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                   29   ,                    49.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:52 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1199   ,           2646   ,         77   ,                       13   ,                   0   ,                   23   ,                    53.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:53 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1197   ,           2646   ,         45   ,                        8   ,                   0   ,                   11   ,                    53.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:54 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1199   ,           2668   ,         33   ,                        9   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    51.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:55 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1199   ,           2668   ,         23   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    58.9   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:56 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1197   ,           2671   ,         11   ,                        5   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    36.4   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:57 ,             1632.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              33   ,                1199   ,           2670   ,         25   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    41.2   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:58 ,             1632.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              33   ,                1197   ,           2670   ,         26   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    41.2   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 13:14:59 ,             1632.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              33   ,                1196   ,           2670   ,         25   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    41.7   ,              16   , 0.8930   ,
2017-08-18 13:15:00 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              33   ,                1199   ,           2670   ,         27   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    36.4   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:15:01 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              33   ,                1199   ,           2670   ,         27   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    35.8   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:15:02 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              33   ,                1196   ,           2670   ,         27   ,                       10   ,                   0   ,                    1   ,                    40.1   ,              16   , 0.8250   ,
2017-08-18 13:15:03 ,             1493.0   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              33   ,                1195   ,           2670   ,         61   ,                       21   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    47.4   ,              16   , 0.9000   ,
2017-08-18 13:15:04 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1195   ,           2670   ,         50   ,                       17   ,                   0   ,                    5   ,                    62.7   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:15:05 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1195   ,           2670   ,         54   ,                       20   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    61.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:15:06 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               61.0   ,              33   ,                1194   ,           2670   ,         51   ,                       19   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    59.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:15:07 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              33   ,                1195   ,           2615   ,         11   ,                        1   ,                   0   ,                    6   ,                    36.3   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:15:08 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              33   ,                1196   ,           2615   ,          0   ,                        0   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    36.2   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:15:09 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               60.0   ,              33   ,                1196   ,           2615   ,          0   ,                        0   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    36.0   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,
2017-08-18 13:15:10 ,             1847.5   ,               5508.0   ,               59.0   ,              33   ,                1196   ,           2615   ,          0   ,                        0   ,                   0   ,                    0   ,                    36.1   ,               4   , 1.0500   ,

 

2017 13" HP Spectre 13" x360 + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10
2016 15" Asus UX501VW GTX960M + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10


ReplyQuote
switch
(@switch)
Trusted Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

I absolutely HATE the way you paste those tables here, but I know it's the only way we can look at them.

 

As you noticed, the BUS load is very low in WOW - exactly as I expected.  However there is some limit on the GPU, as PerfCap Reason of 16 is "GPU Utilization" (I'd wager that the layman's term for this is "this is all that's needed"). For reference, 4 is "Voltage Reliability" - this would imply some form of bottleneck. We see it later in AC.

In AC you get to 29% bus load which means that 100% is PCIe x4 (since PCIe x4 is 25% of PCIe x16 and 29% of PCIe x16 is more than PCIe x4). Also we see PerfCap 4 which means not enough volts (I get that too all the time while gaming). For the record, 29% of PCIe x4 is pretty much the upper limit in H2D transfer (with current firmware). Do the math: 29% of 40Gbps is 11.6Gbps which is pretty much half of the 22Gbps that TB3 can deliver for PCIe.

 

So... you get poor results in WOW but it's unlikely to be directly related to the EXTERNAL nature of your GPU. More like drivers/optimizations. You DO get bottle-necked on the BUS side while gaming in AC.

2016 15" HP ZBook 15 G3 (Xeon E3-1545M, Iris Pro p580, no dGPU) + [email protected] (Aorus Gaming Box) + Win10pro
2018 15" HP ZBook 15 G5 (i7-8850H, HD630, Quadro P1000) + [email protected] (Aorus Gaming Box) + Win10pro


ReplyQuote
Jaye
 Jaye
(@jaye)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

I hate those tables too 😀

So, it seems like bottleneck caused by different things depending on game. 

AC bottleneck due H2D speeds whereas WoW is about something else.

I tried to contact Intel again regarding 22GB - they just send me to whatever laptop manufacturer to replicate issue. It is like some ball game - everyone sends you to somewhere else.

Intel support officially doesn't provide any thunderbolt interface support at all, neither thunderbolttechnology website. 

2017 13" HP Spectre 13" x360 + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10
2016 15" Asus UX501VW GTX960M + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10


ReplyQuote
switch
(@switch)
Trusted Member
Joined: 2 years ago

ReplyQuote
goalque
(@goalque)
Noble Member Admin
Joined: 3 years ago
 

@Jaye: In extremely bandwidth-intensive games, the Bus usage goes only up to 42% peak at FHD resolution. At UHD resolution and lower FPS, only a 12% peak. However, pushing pixels to D2H direction (accelerated internal screen) can increase the Bus usage up to 96%, so there is indeed correlation but I wouldn’t trust these numbers since Nvidia has said that Bus usage is wholly inaccurate.

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/graphics-performance-myths-debunked,3739-4.html

"The bus interface ("BUS") metric refers to utilization of the PCIe controller, again, as a percentage. The corresponding measurement, which you can trace in EVGA PrecisionX and MSI Afterburner, is called "GPU BUS Usage".

We asked Nvidia to shed some light on the inner workings of NVAPI. Its response confirmed that the FB metric measures graphics memory bandwidth usage, but Nvidia dismissed the BUS metric as "considered to be unreliable and thus not used internally".

automate-eGPU EFIapple_set_os.efi
--
2018 13" MacBook Pro + Radeon [email protected] + Win10 1809


Jaye liked
ReplyQuote
tcastelli
(@tcastelli)
Active Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

Hello, I'm new here and after checking the buyers guide and this post  I'm still not sure if the Omen accelerator is suffering from the H2D problem or if it already has a firmware update that solves the problem.

Can anyone confirm that? 🙂

Thanks

Pending: Add my system information and expected eGPU configuration to my signature to give context to my posts


ReplyQuote
Jaye
 Jaye
(@jaye)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

Just reported fps drop (48fps on any resolution) issue to ASUS - they promised to send this issue to a tech team. I tried to explain issue as detailed as possible. I also mentioned egpu.io forums and representative asked again forum's address to write it down to case. I told that not only XG2 Station is affected, if they will be able to do something with that - most likely other devs would be able. 

Moreover, ThunderboltTechnology on Facebook replied to me - they told that they revamped their support and now they do accept and reply to Facebook messages to them.  Their answer: "We will push along your concerns to some higher ups 🙂" I mentioned also 22GB throttle and this forum.

Few days ago I've seen, somewhere on web, testing of egpu enclosure both with Radeon and Geforce graphics. Curiously, Radeon performed much better in games that I've mentioned in fps drop issue - GTA5 fps is stable according to fps charts. Optimized drivers? NVidia added official support for Quadro series - I've placed request over their online chat to add official support for Geforce series too. (They told that only Titan X among geforce, as for now, officially supported for use as eGPU). Customer representative promised to deliver my request to tech team too.

Who knows, maybe we will get something from all this.

2017 13" HP Spectre 13" x360 + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10
2016 15" Asus UX501VW GTX960M + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10


wimpzilla and nando4 liked
ReplyQuote
4chip4
(@4chip4)
Estimable Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 
Posted by: tcastelli

Hello, I'm new here and after checking the buyers guide and this post  I'm still not sure if the Omen accelerator is suffering from the H2D problem or if it already has a firmware update that solves the problem.

Can anyone confirm that? 🙂

Thanks

I believe the reason for low speeds in that particular post were down to the host (laptop) BIOS in question (see  https://egpu.io/forums/pc-setup/aero-15-hq7700-low-tb3-bandwidth-issue/ from @Denjin who posted it on the HP forum).

I'm seeing a symmetrical 1450MB/s performance on my x2 setup, so unless the half-H2D issue doesn't manifest on x2 lane systems, I'd say it's likely not affected (x4 systems with the half H2D issue have reported slower speeds than my x2 one). Worst case scenario - check for the policy and you can ship it back if it's incompatible with your system.

2017 HP Spectre x360 15 i7-8550U GTX150 + GTX970@16Gbps-TB3 (HP Omen Accelerator) + Oculus Rift + Win10 (no guide)
HP Omen Accelerator Thunderbolt 3 enclosure legs stand removal walkthrough
Employed by HP, but my posts and opinions expressed on this forum are my own.


itsage liked
ReplyQuote
itsage
(@itsage)
Famed Member Admin
Joined: 3 years ago
 

The OMEN Accelerator doesn’t have this H2D issue. You can easily identify it when the Host-to-Device reading for a Thunderbolt 3 connection is at 1,1XX MiB/s in CUDA-Z. The only exception is with the TB3 15″ MacBook Pro in which the Host-to-Device reading may show 1,3XX MiB/s. 

Best ultrabooks for eGPU use

eGPU enclosure buying guide


4chip4 liked
ReplyQuote
wimpzilla
(@wimpzilla)
Honorable Member
Joined: 3 years ago
 
Posted by: Jaye

Just reported fps drop (48fps on any resolution) issue to ASUS - they promised to send this issue to a tech team. I tried to explain issue as detailed as possible. I also mentioned egpu.io forums and representative asked again forum's address to write it down to case. I told that not only XG2 Station is affected, if they will be able to do something with that - most likely other devs would be able. 

Moreover, ThunderboltTechnology on Facebook replied to me - they told that they revamped their support and now they do accept and reply to Facebook messages to them.  Their answer: "We will push along your concerns to some higher ups 🙂" I mentioned also 22GB throttle and this forum.

Few days ago I've seen, somewhere on web, testing of egpu enclosure both with Radeon and Geforce graphics. Curiously, Radeon performed much better in games that I've mentioned in fps drop issue - GTA5 fps is stable according to fps charts. Optimized drivers? NVidia added official support for Quadro series - I've placed request over their online chat to add official support for Geforce series too. (They told that only Titan X among geforce, as for now, officially supported for use as eGPU). Customer representative promised to deliver my request to tech team too.

Who knows, maybe we will get something from all this.

Nice job Sir, thanks you!

Providing a good TB base performance to start with is sure useful, to drive further manufacturer devices implementations, along technology development and growth.

2012 13-inch Dell Latitude E6320 + R9 [email protected] (EXP GDC 8.4) + Win10
E=Mc²


ReplyQuote
tcastelli
(@tcastelli)
Active Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 
Posted by: itsage

The OMEN Accelerator doesn't have this H2D issue. You can easily identify it when the Host-to-Device reading for a Thunderbolt 3 connection is at 1,1XX MiB/s in CUDA-Z. The only exception is with the TB3 15" MacBook Pro in which the Host-to-Device reading may show 1,3XX MiB/s. 

Thanks for the suggestion, couldn't find any picture from someone using it with the requirements to get the full 22Gbps and started to think that maybe it was also suffering from H2D.

Pending: Add my system information and expected eGPU configuration to my signature to give context to my posts


ReplyQuote
Azrael
(@azrael)
Active Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 
[Gigabyte Aorus GTX 1070 GAMING BOX]

I have been in contact with Gigabyte support to ask them about the h2d issue. This is the second answer, after the first one was very evasive:

Our engineers are looking into the issue and will release a new firmware on website soon. If there is any update, we will post on product website page. Sorry for inconvenience.

So... somewhat good news, but we'll have to wait and see...

Pending: Add my system information and expected eGPU configuration to my signature to give context to my posts


ReplyQuote
Zihan Li
(@zihan)
New Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

The half H2D performance issue also appears on Sonnet Breakaway Box 350. Following is my cuda-z report, H2D is only 1600 M/s. Is there any solution to that?

CUDA-Z Report

=============

Version: 0.10.251 64 bit http://cuda-z.sf.net/

OS Version: Mac OS X 10.12.6 16G29

Driver Version: 10.17.5 355.10.05.45f01

Driver Dll Version: 8.0

Runtime Dll Version: 6.50

 

Core Information

----------------

Name: GeForce GTX 1080

Compute Capability: 6.1

Clock Rate: 1733.5 MHz

 

Performance Information

-----------------------

Memory Copy

Host Pinned to Device: 1681.7 MiB/s

Host Pageable to Device: 1668.52 MiB/s

Device to Host Pinned: 2699.97 MiB/s

Device to Host Pageable: 2643.47 MiB/s

Device to Device: 105.324 GiB/s

Generated: Sat Aug 26 10:01:37 2017

 

Pending: Add my system information and expected eGPU configuration to my signature to give context to my posts


ReplyQuote
itsage
(@itsage)
Famed Member Admin
Joined: 3 years ago
 

@Zihan What Thunderbolt 3 host are you running? The telltale sign for H2D issue is when Host-to-Device number is showing 1,1XX MiB/s. 

Best ultrabooks for eGPU use

eGPU enclosure buying guide


ReplyQuote
Zihan Li
(@zihan)
New Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 
I run the test on 2016 15" MacBook Pro with RP455 

Pending: Add my system information and expected eGPU configuration to my signature to give context to my posts


ReplyQuote
Jaye
 Jaye
(@jaye)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

Some updates:

I've also (I've asked through support representative before) asked for eGPU support from nVidia by messaging Software QA @ nVidia - Manuel Guzman. (just accidentally found him on Twitter. Maybe it will help somehow :D)

Got a call and email from ASUS: their engineering team asked me to provide pictures\videos of fps drop issue. I already recorded performance in AC Black Flag and WoW Legion, added comments  and sent to them. Waiting for further updates from ASUS.

2017 13" HP Spectre 13" x360 + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10
2016 15" Asus UX501VW GTX960M + [email protected] (AKiTiO Node) + Win10


ReplyQuote
switch
(@switch)
Trusted Member
Joined: 2 years ago
 

I *think* that there's a new firmware for the Aorus, fixing H2D bandwidth.

2016 15" HP ZBook 15 G3 (Xeon E3-1545M, Iris Pro p580, no dGPU) + [email protected] (Aorus Gaming Box) + Win10pro
2018 15" HP ZBook 15 G5 (i7-8850H, HD630, Quadro P1000) + [email protected] (Aorus Gaming Box) + Win10pro


ReplyQuote
 of  8