Sonnet Breakaway Puck Review – Pint-sized Compromise

eGPU Reviews 11 Comments

Introduction

With a dozen Thunderbolt 3 eGPU enclosures currently available on the market, we now have more options that either maximize performance or portability. The latest entry is the Breakaway Puck from Sonnet Tech. Built to be the most portable external graphics solution (eGFX), it’s neither particularly powerful nor cost-conscious. The Sonnet Breakaway Puck is intended for multi-monitor expansion or as a compact setup for eSports gaming. Sonnet is catering to a niche group of customers in a very niche market, and I commend its commitment. So for those whose needs are perfectly met by a handheld eGPU, it’s the best thing since sliced bread.

Hardware Specifics

Sonnet Breakaway Puck - the size of a slice of bread

Sonnet Breakaway Puck meets a slice of bread

Specifications  compare 
Price US$
$399 | $599
Included GPU RX560 | RX570
Max PCIe bandwidth 32Gbps
PSU location-type
external-AC
PSU max power 160W | 220W
Power delivery (PD)
45W
USB-C controller
TI83
TB3 USB-C ports 1
USB3.0 ports (+C type)
Ethernet & SATA  port
Other ports 3xDP,HDMI
Size (in/mm, LxWxH)
6.00 x 2.00 x 5.12
152 x 51 x 130
Weight (kg/lb) 2.38/5.25
Updated firmware 25.1 ✔
Implementations
link

Recent studies show American youth is losing their grip strength. Tech companies share some of the blame with their continuous advancements in the workplace and through thinner and lighter electronics. The Sonnet Breakaway Puck is a very clear example of this trend. It took the bulk and mass of a typical eGPU enclosure by relocating the power supply externally. Instead of building an enclosure large enough to house a PCIe graphics card, the Breakaway Puck uses an MXM GPU. Compared to the Breakaway Box that weighs more than 7 lbs, this Puck weighs in under 5.25 lbs including the AC adapter. You need both hands to handle the Breakaway Box. That’s not the case with the Puck.

The four rubber feet at the bottom of the enclosure serve as covers for Philips screws. Opening this bottom cover to access the internal components will void your warranty. The metal housing is very sturdy. Its top cover features a Sonnet Tech logo which glows blue when active. This is also a point of air intake through mesh windows. The single fan disperses heat from the heatsink through cutouts on the sides. Sandwiched in between the heatsink and main Thunderbolt board is the MXM graphics card.

Using an AC adapter to power an external graphics card is a concept most eGPU enthusiasts are familiar with. Prior to the all-in-one enclosure with an internal PSU design, we have been building eGPU boxes out of the AKiTiO Thunder2 and Thunder3. The PSU of choice was often a Dell DA-2 220W. Sonnet enhanced this concept in the Breakaway Puck. It uses a Mean Well 160W power brick for the RX 560 media sample I received. This PSU is both lighter and smaller than the Dell DA-2.

The cooling fan is a 75mm unit made by Apistek. It’s whisper quiet most of the time. The only occasion I noticed it running full speed was during initiation with the host computer to activate AMD XConnect. This process only lasts a few seconds. I can’t speak for the RX 570 version, but in the Sonnet Breakaway Puck RX 560 this cooling fan is sufficient. With the power supply not located inside the enclosure, this eGPU runs relatively cool.

The Sonnet Breakaway Puck contains a Thunderbolt 3 main board that’s arranged to uniquely work with an MXM card. The main differences with the other eGPU enclosure boards are a slot for the MXM card and the video output ports. Next to the Thunderbolt 3 port are an assortment of one HDMI and three DisplayPorts. The crucial controllers and IC for a Thunderbolt 3 external graphics card are all here: Texas Instrument TP865983 USB-C controller, Intel DSL6540 Thunderbolt 3 controller, and Winbond EEPROM.

Testings & Benchmarks

I’m not the target audience for this enclosure, but my wife immediately saw the appeal of this Sonnet Breakaway Puck, asking why all the other enclosures I reviewed were so large. The Puck has the same appeal as a Mac mini – a very small footprint, compact enough for you to pick it up just to admire the form factor. It just made sense to pair this Breakaway Puck RX 560 with a Mac mini for testing in macOS.

Breakaway Puck with Mac mini and Lenovo Yoga 920

The RX 570 version (shares same PCI ID 67DF with RX 580) is plug-and-play with macOS 10.13 native eGPU support. The RX 560 however does not have this same fate. It’s not hard to enable eGPU for it though. Goalque created and packaged automate-eGPU.kext installer for 10.13 to make this process easy. Once I ran this installer, the Sonnet Breakaway RX 560 works great with a 2011 Mac mini via the Apple USB-C/Thunderbolt 3 to Thunderbolt adapter (Thunderbolt 1 speed). The process is the same as with the natively supported RX 570/580; I hot plug the eGPU, macOS notifies me to log out to enable external GPU then log back in to use.

Power delivery is only possible when paired with a Thunderbolt 3 host computer. I tested with a late 2016 15″ MacBook Pro and saw 45W PD through this Breakaway Puck. Thunderbolt firmware version is 25.1 which should not have the H2D bandwidth issue found in earlier eGPU enclosures.

If you recall back in March this year, I ventured into building a custom AKiTiO Thunder2 RX 470 eGPU and mounted it on the back of a monitor. That idea was very well-received. Sonnet made that a reality in this Puck. It offers a Puckcuff VESA mounting kit ($59) for you to accomplish this same task. For more pictures of the Breakaway Puck and Puckcuff, please read my unboxing post.

For performance testing, an ultrabook would make the best pairing for the intended use of this product. The release of this enclosure coincides with Intel 8th generation quad-core ULV CPU availability. I used a late 2017 Lenovo Yoga 920 for this review. This ultrabook has the i7-8550U that many eGPU enthusiasts anticipate will boost external graphics performance.

I sound like a broken record, but it bears repeating there are two main performance hindrances on ultrabooks paired with eGPU. The first one is PCI Express lane assignment for Thunderbolt 3 connection. The ideal arrangement is 4 data-transmission PCI Express lanes but many come with only 2 lanes. The second issue is whether the laptop is set for low-power GT2 OPI mode or high-performance GT4 OPI mode. This information is unfortunately not available on the spec sheet from the manufacturers. We want to bring more awareness so that eventually the PC OEMs will provide this detail for future products. The good news is this Yoga 920 has both x4 PCIe connection over its Thunderbolt ports and runs in GT4 OPI mode. The Sonnet Breakaway Puck provides sufficient power to charge this laptop through the Thunderbolt 3 cable.

I didn’t have any eSports games to test. Sonnet provided these tests they did in-house. I ran my usual set of synthetic benchmarks, except I changed the settings to Medium at FHD. These were run through the Intel UHD Graphics 620 iGPU with the internal display and Sonnet Breakaway Puck RX 560 eGPU with an external monitor. Here are the numbers:

Lenovo Yoga 920Intel HD 620 iGPUAMD RX 560 eGPU
Unigine Valley4561,559
Unigine Heaven2661,014
Unigine Superposition7982,856
3DMark Time Spy5822,163
3DMark Fire Strike1,1234,807
Tomb Raider 201318.0 FPS70.8 FPS
Shadow of Mordor14.5 FPS49.0 FPS
Dirt Rally15.5 FPS48.8 FPS
Hitman18.0 FPS63.8 FPS

Conclusion

With electronics, smaller and lighter often comes with a hefty price. The Sonnet Breakaway Puck is no exception. It accomplishes the mission of being the most compact external graphics solution on the market. At $399 for the RX 560 and $599 for the RX 570 version, the Breakaway Puck is a compromise on performance given the alternatives. Nevertheless it still roughly quadruples the performance of an Intel iGPU. If portability is the main priority, net yourself a Breakaway Puck.

 

See also

 

Rate this Post

Share this Post

 

Related Articles
  • Best eGPU Enclosures Reviewed - External GPU Buyer's Guide...
    November 14, 2018
  • Akitio Node Duo Tested Pcie Expansion Cards
    AKiTiO Node Duo Review - Two Slots, Endless Possibilities
    October 15, 2018
    3
  • State of eGPU for Macs – Mojave 10.14 Update
    October 13, 2018
    70
  • Asus Xg Station Pro Strix Gtx 1080 Ti 2016 15 In Macbook Pro
    ASUS XG Station Pro Review - Cool, Calm and...
    August 16, 2018
    58
  • Blackmagic Egpu Radeon Pro 580 Alienware 15 R3
    Blackmagic eGPU Review - Apple's UltraFine Curse
    July 31, 2018
    39
  • Razer Core X Handle Opened
    Razer Core X Review - Thick and Juicy
    May 22, 2018
    32
  • Gigabyte RX 580 Gaming Box Review - Little in...
    May 7, 2018
    70
  • macOS External GPU Review - Out-of-Body Experiment
    May 3, 2018
    45
  • Mantiz Titan Thunderbolt 3 Dock
    Mantiz Titan Thunderbolt 3 Dock Review - #Donglelife Simplified
    April 23, 2018
    35
  • Zotac AMP BOX Mini Review - Budget Friendly, Promise...
    March 19, 2018
    16
  • Lenovo Thunderbolt 3 Graphics Dock Review - Dead on...
    March 12, 2018
    25
  • AKiTiO Node Pro Review - Jack of All Trades
    February 12, 2018
    38
  • Hands-on with Lenovo Thunderbolt 3 Graphics Dock
    January 11, 2018
    29
  • Hands-on with ASUS XG Station Pro Thunderbolt 3 Enclosure
    January 10, 2018
    17
  • Razer Core V2 Review - Think Inside the Box
    January 1, 2018
    11
  • ASUS ROG XG Station 2 Review - Irresponsible Power
    December 20, 2017
    11
  • Gigabyte AORUS GTX 1080 Gaming Box Review – Tiny...
    November 3, 2017
    69
  • OMEN Accelerator Review - HP's External GPU Voodoo Doll
    October 14, 2017
    34
  • Unboxing: Sonnet eGFX Breakaway Puck
    October 4, 2017
    31
  • Gigabyte AORUS GTX 1070 Gaming Box Review - Tiny...
    August 11, 2017
    237
  • Unboxing: Gigabyte AORUS GTX 1070 Gaming Box
    August 4, 2017
    5
  • Netstor Hercules HL23T Review - Speak Softly and Carry...
    July 31, 2017
    65
  • The Makings of a Good Thunderbolt 3 Host -...
    July 5, 2017
    6
  • Alienware Graphics Amplifier Review - Faster than Thunderbolt 3...
    June 16, 2017
    25
  • Razer Core Review - an eGPU Enclosure Built for...
    June 8, 2017
  • RX 580 External GPU Review - AMD XConnect and...
    May 27, 2017
    29
  • Sonnet Breakaway Box Review - It's cool to be...
    April 30, 2017
    43
  • Unboxing: Sonnet eGFX Breakaway Box
    April 26, 2017
    17
  • Mantiz Venus Review: All-in-one Thunderbolt 3 eGPU Docking Station
    March 26, 2017
    45
  • AKiTiO Node Review & The State of Thunderbolt 3...
    January 7, 2017
    28
  • Unboxing: AKiTiO Node Thunderbolt 3 eGPU Enclosure
    December 15, 2016
    9
  • Acer Graphics Dock Review
    December 6, 2016
    21

 

11
Leave a Reply

avatar
8 Comment threads
3 Thread replies
2 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
10 Comment authors
theitsageTaikuhcmmashfreqknombrescreeno Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
wusel
Member

Thanks for the nice review. The first picture is really cool. It should be a new standard to compare tech dimensions with a toast or even better – a new unit: “My new notebook is only 4 toasts” 😀

adamtoday
Guest

I think this eGPU is far from being perfect. It is targeted for doing work rather than gaming. It should have an internal SATA or Nvme support, a Lan and mix of some USB ports otherwise it is a waste of TH3 port!

Hopefully, we can have a newer model that can give us more GPU option up to mobile 1080.

Flash315
Member

The new node pro coming soon I think will improve on a few of those questions, the form factor of the aorus 1080 box and the sonnet Puck (although there is a huge difference in performance between the two) i think will be the standard for future portability audiences especially gamers 

NobodyKnowsYourName
Guest

Does the Puck’s GPU go to sleep with the Macbook? Or does it keep running? I heard the HP Omen Accellerators GPU does not go to sleep when you put your Mac into sleep mode.

C4PPY
Member

Has anyone tried with a different MXM card?
Was thinking that you could take a GTX10xxM card and install instead would give you close to real GPU power in a much smaller footprint?

nombrescreeno
Member

Posted by: C4PPY
Has anyone tried with a different MXM card?
Was thinking that you could take a GTX10xxM card and install instead would give you close to real GPU power in a much smaller footprint?

I’m curious about this too. MXM cards can be pricy, but are a viable upgrade path if that works!

ashfreqk
Member

has anyone used this with mbp 2017/2016 bootcamp? Would be glad to know how it works out:)

mois
Member

Discussion about the optimal Thunderbolt 3 eGPU for driving the 8K Dell UP3218K display here https://egpu.io/forums/thunderbolt-enclosures/drive-the-8k-display-dell-up3218k-fed-via-two-dp1-4-using-sonnet-puck-560-570-or-other-solution-thoughts-comments/ . I would have hoped the Puck would be optimal but maybe only Nvidia are stable enough, err. If anyone has experiences or thoughts please share, thanks!

Taikuh
Member

Hi @itsage, in your opinion, is it possible to modify the innards of the Puck to fit inside a Unibody Mac Mini? It would have to be 2.5 cm thick at most, I think.